B&W or Color?

[DaveB]

The skin is way too soft and blurry for my taste.

[SnJPhotography]

I like BW for this kind of thing, but as others have ssaid, the image looks flat. Would you mind I f I tried a couple things in PS and emailed it back to you?

Cheers.

Scott

[trwphoto]

Someone besides me actually looks at the artistic outlook of a photo and not the tec. side? (Back pat to you frend) So many times i see comments on photos that aren't perfectly exposed and is absolutly beautful and the only thing you hear is "It is over,under, color, and miss the point completely.

[natalia.Taffarel]

Originally Posted by trwphoto

Someone besides me actually looks at the artistic outlook of a photo and not the tec. side? (Back pat to you frend) So many times i see comments on photos that aren't perfectly exposed and is absolutly beautful and the only thing you hear is "It is over,under, color, and miss the point completely.

I don't think it's about that at all. When I look at an image I'm not trying to find the fault, but if something bothers me about it, I look back.
In this case, I love the image, model, idea and lighting. But the efect can be achived without losing depth and texture of the skin.