This will be my last post on this particular topic.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ARTFORMS
Just because this pose was not liked by a particular photographer giving a critique does not automatically make it bad.
|
In general, technically, this is a true statement. But a pose that makes one breast look twice the size of the other is not a stellar achievement to be proud of. When a photographer's reponsibility in this matter's was pointed out:
Quote:
|
It is up to the photographer to notice the dissimilar breast size and correct for it whether it is wardrobe or a posing function. She can't see it from her point of view and is counting on the photographer's eyes to help her look her best.
|
You responded by going into denial:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ARTFORMS
if it is her anotomy there isn't anything that any photographer can do about it
|
Despite just having gotten suggestions on what to do about it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ARTFORMS
After talking to the other photographer recently I ask him how he managed to get Quincy's skin color to look pink. He admited that she isn't really pink. She had a slight tan. You may like the pose better on the image he posted. The lighting on both images was identical to each other.
|
It was obvious that the two of you either had different white balance settings or simply post processed differently, due to the large differences in her skin tones, the bow and the seamless, but that is not the topic here. Why are you trying to deflect the issue?
Quote:
Originally Posted by ARTFORMS
The reply given about her tattoo on her foot was based on the person not liking it which is a personal thing on his part and not in my control at least not unless I were to edit it out but she was the customer and did not request that. So the comment was about her asthetic appearance in that case. The tattoo is seen in both images so we might think that if he were to comment on that image that the same dislike of that would be there but he did not do so.
|
You need to be less defensive when you read negative comments about the pictures that you post. You are imagining things. Here is the full text of the one and only comment that mentions the tattoo:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Soujrnr
Hi Jim. Gorgeous lady but I don't like the way her breasts seem so totally different from one another. Her left breast looks huge while the right one looks much smaller. Maybe its the way the top fits but the effect really doesn't do much for me personally. Other than that, nice shot and an interesting tat on her right foot. That HAD to hurt having that tattoed right on top of the foot bone. OUCH.
Good day sir!
Mike
|
Please point out the part where he says he
doesn't like it. Perhaps this is something that you can admit to making a mistake about? But then your whole defense of people criticizing aesthetic choices that are beyond your control would fall apart.